The Old Wine Shades Read online

  VIKING

  Published by the Penguin Group

  Penguin Group (USA) Inc., 375 Hudson Street,

  New York, New York 10014, U.S.A.

  Penguin fdrotlp (Canada), 90 Eglinton Avenue East, Suite 700, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M4P 2Y3 (a division of Pearson Penguin Canada Inc.) Penguin Books Ltd, 80 Strand, London WC2R 0RL, England Penguin lr~[apd, 25 St. Stephen’s Green, Dublin 2, Ireland (a division of Penguin Books Ltd)

  Penguin Books Australia Ltd, 250 Camberwetl Road, Camberwell, Victoria 3124, Australia (a division of Pearson Australia Group Pty Ltd) Penguin Books India Pvt Ltd, 11 Community Centre, Panchsheel Park, New Delhi -110 017, India

  Penguin Group (NZ), Cnr Airborne and Rosedale Roads, Albany, Auckland 1310, New Zealand (a division of Pearson New Zealand Ltd Penguin Books (South Africa) (Pty) Ltd, 24 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg 2196, South Afi’ica

  Penguin Books Ltd, Registered Offices: 80 Strand, London WC2R 0RL, England

  First published in 2006 by Viking Penguin, a member of Penguin Group (USA) Inc.

  1357910864

  Copyright © Martha Grimes, 2006 All rights reserved

  Grateful acknowledgment is made for permission to reprint an excerpt from ‘The Pauper Witch of Grafton’ from The Poetry of Robert Frost edited by Edward Connery Lathem. Copyright 1928, 1969 by Henry Holt and Company. Copyright 1956 by Robert Frost. Reprinted by permission of Henry Holt and Company.

  Publisher’s Note: This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents either are the product of the author’s imagination or are used fictitiously, and any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, business establishments, events, or locales is entirely coincidental.

  ISBN 0-670-03479-7

  Printed in the United States of America Set in Bodoni Book Designed by Francesca Belanger

  Without limiting the rights under copyright reserved above, no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in or introduced into a retrieval system, or transnfitted, in any form or by any means (electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise), without the prior written permission of both the copyright owner and the above publisher of this book. The scanning, uploading, and distribution of this book via the Internet or via any other means without the permission of the publisher is illegal and punishable by law. Please purchase only authorized electronic editions and do not participate in or encourage electronic piracy of copyrightable materials. Your support of the author’s rights is appreciated.

  To Vicki

  and in memory Dodger

  They don’t dispose me, either one of them,

  To spare them any trouble.

  Double trouble’s

  Always the witch’s motto anyway.

  I’ll double theirs for both of them–you watch me.

  They’ll find they’ve got the whole thing to do over.

  From ‘The Pauper Witch of Grafton’ by Robert Frost

  MAN WALKED INTO A PUB

  Prologue

  (From The Winds of Change)

  They sat in silence for a moment. Then Harry Johnson said, ‘If you want a story, I’ll tell you a story–though I can’t explain it, or tell you the end; there isn’t any end.’

  ‘Sounds intriguing.

  ‘Oh, it’s intriguing, all right.’

  ‘Go on.’

  ‘It happened to a friend of mine. This person, who was the luckiest person I’ve ever known–you could almost say was hounded by good luck–lost everything overnight.’

  ‘Bloody hell. You mean in a market crash, something like that?’

  ‘No, no. Not money. I mean he lost everything. He woke up one morning and found himself sans wife, son, even his dog. He did not know what had happened, and of course no one would believe him and he had no idea what to do. He considered going to the police, but what in hell would he say? They wouldn’t believe him, I mean wouldn’t believe the wife, the son, the dog had simply disappeared; well, you know how bloody-minded police can be–’

  ‘I do indeed.’ Jury smiled in a crazy kind of way.

  ‘Right. Families don’t all of a sudden disappear–I mean, unless some psychopath walks in and murders them all. He told me he felt he was living in a parallel universe, that his wife and son were in one and he was in another.’

  ‘Then what did he do?’

  ‘He hired the best private detectives. They found nothing, not a trace. There was simply no trail.’ Harry stopped, took out another cigarette, offered the case to Jury again, and Jury again refused.

  ‘That was a year ago.’

  ‘And?’’ It struck Jury suddenly, the answer to the question he had glumly posed to himself earlier: what kept him going? Here was the answer: curiosity. He waited for Harry Johnson to fill in the blank after ‘And—’

  Harry lit his cigarette, blew out a stream of smoke and said, ‘The dog came back.’

  Jury stared. ‘This is a joke, right?’

  Unsmiling, Harry Johnson said, ‘No, it isn’t. The dog just came back.’ They were both silent for a moment while Harry Johnson seemed to be collecting himself. ‘So do you want to hear the rest of it?’ Dumbly, Jury nodded.

  Man walked into a pub...

  1

  Harry Johnson lit another cigarette, flipped his lighter shut and said, ‘You’re not convinced, I can see. I’m not joking.’ Richard Jury just looked at him, and seeing the man was not about to back down from his improbable tale (for surely that’s what it was, a ‘tale’), Jury could only laugh, turn back to the bar and pick up his pint. ‘Come on. ‘The dog came back.’’ He drank.

  ‘Wife, son, dog disappear, and the dog came back. After how long, did you say? A year?’

  ‘Nearly. Nine, ten months, perhaps.’ Harry Johnson blew a big smoke ring and then a little one straight through it.

  That really rankled. The man was clearly well off if that cashmere coat, that gold ring bore testimony; handsome–just the sort who made other men feel tatty; intelligent and well spoken. And besides all that he could blow proper smoke rings.

  Intriguing, too, don’t forget that. Even though Jury didn’t believe him. ‘The dog came back, sure.’ Jury laughed again, a little too abruptly, perhaps, a little too indicative that Jury himself couldn’t take a joke. Well, but that was the point, wasn’t it? According to this Harry Johnson, it was no joke.

  Harry Johnson smiled, set down his whiskey and got up. ‘Can you wait here a minute while I go to my car?’

  ‘Me? Oh, sure, got all the time in the–’ But Harry Johnson was gone before he finished. Jury looked down the bar, wishing the barman were up at this end so he could ask him about this fellow.

  The barman had called him by name, acted as if Johnson was often in here. But the barman was down there talking to a raucous couple with toothy smiles and hackers’ coughs. There were times Jury thought the entire world smoked except for him, Killjoy Jury.

  He looked down at his empty glass. Had that been number two? Three? Was he getting drunk?

  The door to the pub opened and Harry Johnson was back with a dog on a lead.

  He sat down and smiled and so did the dog. Sat down, that is, not smiled. It was a medium-sized dog, nothing special, a hound of some sort, the kind you’d pick out at the shelter to adopt, flop-eared, tan and white coat, immediately likable, the kind of dog you itched to scratch between the ears. It was sitting in its lopsided way, the way dogs do, and Jury reached down and scratched his head.

  ‘Are you telling me this is the dog, then?’

  ‘He’s the one.’

  Jury looked from Harry Johnson to the dog. ‘What’s his name?’

  ‘Mungo.’ Harry held up his empty glass, and Trevor, the barman, came along, smiling, and refilled it. Ju
ry declined, thinking he had drunk a great deal in a short period of time. ‘We’ve an excellent Batard, ‘85. Full and fat,’ the barman said. ‘You’re drinking whiskey tonight?’ There was the hint of a reproach in his voice.

  ‘That’s pretty obvious, Trev.’ Harry smiled, no slight intended.

  He said to Jury, ‘Trevor is the wine fellow. I mean the wine fellow. The expert. I’m not sure the others can tell the difference between a Pouilly-fussé and Pellegrino.’

  ‘Then they’re the ones I should order from, not knowing myself,’ said Jury.

  Trevor said, ‘Come on, Mr. Johnson, we’re not that bad.’

  ‘You’re not, no. Maybe we’ll switch in a minute.’

  Trevor shook his head. ‘Not after that single malt you’re drinking.’ He slid his look over to Jury’s glass. That wasn’t even worth evaluation. Trevor walked off.

  Harry laughed. ‘Wine is not something you fool around with, not where Trevor’s concerned.’

  ‘So Mungo–’

  Here the dog sat up a bit, alert.

  ‘Showed up at your friend’s place–wait a minute–the ‘friend’ isn’t going to turn out to be you yourself, is he?’

  ‘Good lord, no.’

  ‘All right, but remember, it’s you who has the dog.’

  ‘I found Mungo sitting outside Hugh’s front door. That’s the friend’s name, Hugh Gauh. This was their home, in Chelsea, not far from mine, in Belgravia. He’s a good friend of mine, Hugh, so I expect that’s why Mungo was willing to come with me. I’d gone to the house to pick up a few books and things. Hugh is seriously thinking about putting the house on the market, but somehow I doubt he will. I think he’s afraid that as soon as he’s done it, his wife and son would turn up with no place to go.’

  ‘But he doesn’t live there?’

  ‘No. The whole thing nearly sent him over the edge. He’s in a private clinic in Fulham.’

  ‘Psychiatric, you mean?’

  Harry nodded. ‘All of this drove him into a deep depression. He’s much better now.’

  Jury felt the dog edge under his bar chair.

  ‘Anyway, Mungo was waiting there at the door, I don’t know for how long. He looked worn out and hungry and after I let him in I went to fetch food for him. But what he did instead of eating was to go from room to room, sniffing, investigating, taking a long time at it. Then he attacked his bowl of food as if he meant to eat right through it and the floor. I gave him more, and he ate that, too. He drank a bucketful of water. Then I took him home with me. I live in Belgravia, or did I mention that?’

  Not a shabby address, thought Jury, but then there was that black cashmere coat Jury couldn’t stop coveting. ‘Is it possible your friend Hugh fantasized all of this?’

  Harry Johnson just looked at him. It was a disappointed look.

  ‘And I did too? Fantasized Hugh and family? Don’t be ridiculous. Is that the best you can do?’

  Jury laughed. He was glad he hadn’t told Johnson he was a detective with the Met. A detective superintendent, no less. And he certainly wasn’t going to tell him now. Jury’s question had been incredibly lame. ‘I take it that’s a no?’

  ‘Unless you think I’m fantasizing it too.’

  ‘It’s a possibility.’

  ‘Oh, please.’

  ‘You could be winding me up.’

  ‘Why? Why would I walk into a pub and start telling a perfect stranger a story that isn’t true?’

  ‘I don’t know. I expect I’ll find out at some point. But go on.’ Jury looked down at Mungo, who’d crawled back out from under the chair and who raised his eyes when he sensed Jury’s own on him.

  ‘How do you explain Mungo?’

  ‘Coming back? Well, there’ve always been tales of animals finding their way home from long distances, these miraculous treks to find their homes. What was that book that was so popular when I was a teenager? The Incredible Journey, wasn’t it?’

  ‘But it took Mungo nine months?’ He looked down; the dog was looking up at him in what Jury would describe as a beseeching manner.

  ‘I still detect an edge of sarcasm. I doubt Mungo was traveling for nine or ten months, but as I don’t know what had transpired in those months, I don’t know how even to guess. But maybe they don’t forget the way we do. There are times I can’t even remember what street I live on.’

  Jury smiled. ‘Sorry about the sarcasm. Did the husband report this to the police?’

  ‘Of course. You can imagine how Surrey police reacted to all of this: if the wife and boy were truly missing, then the prime suspect would be Hugh himself. But that’s England’s finest. No imagination, none at all.’

  ‘I’ll drink to that.’ Jury held up his glass, and Trevor came down the bar. ‘Hugh went to Surrey?’ His curiosity deepened with everything Harry told him. He watched Trevor fill his glass.

  ‘Hugh? Not initially. I went for him. He got stuck on the idea that Glynnis and Robbie would be back and he wouldn’t be there to see them.’ Harry went on. ‘They might have been murdered, they might have been kidnapped, or–as was the popular theory at the outset–unhappy wife leaves husband and takes the child with her. That was so ridiculous I couldn’t understand how police held on to it.’

  ‘But it was a likely explanation. After all, the police didn’t know the wife as well as you do.’ Jury had been about to say It’s the one I would have gone for before he stopped himself. Instead he said, looking down at the dog, ‘So only Mungo knows.’

  ‘Whatever is known, right.’

  ‘You said at the outset you’d tell me the rest of it.’ Harry Johnson nodded. ‘It was last year, in the summer, in July, I think. That morning Glynn–that’s Glynnis–with Robbie and Mungo in tow, Glynnis set out for a look round the countryside in Surrey. She was viewing houses. They wanted a house outside of London.’

  ‘Second home? Weekend cottage sort of thing?’

  ‘Not exactly–I’ll get around to that later. Anyway, Glynn was to meet up with an estate agent who had a couple of listings she thought were worth seeing. They were about a half mile apart near a village called Lark Rise. She had appointments to see both houses, one still occupied and one empty. One she thought a complete toss, said it was too quaint and whimsical. She called the agent and told her what she thought and that she was then going to drive to the second house. The agent’s name is Marjorie Bathous, and she’s with a firm called Forester and Flynn. They’re located in Lark Rise.’

  ‘But Glynn didn’t call a second time. The agent calculated it would take only a few minutes to get to the second house, but was allowing time for Glynn to look around. That was a generous allowance, she said, since Glynnis was the type who knew what she liked immediately, at first glance. Well, when she hadn’t heard from her after an hour, she began to get concerned, thinking perhaps she’d lost her way, or was having car trouble or something. When she didn’t hear after an hour and a half, she really got anxious.’

  ‘Didn’t she try Glynnis’s mobile phone?’’

  ‘She hadn’t got the number. She said if there’d been trouble, well, Mrs. Gault would have called her. So then this Marjorie Bathous got in her car and drove to house number one. It took her about twenty minutes from Forester and Flynn. When she got to the first house, she called in. The couple there told the agent that yes, they’d been there, even had had a cup of tea, but had left some time ago. So the agent drove to the second house. What she thought she might find was that their car had broken down, but if there had been that kind of trouble, she thought Glynnis would have called her.

  When she got to house number two there was no sign of anyone.

  ‘That house was listed as available on a long lease, not for sale. Anyway, there was no use asking at the door as the place was vacant. Still, she looked around the house and grounds for some clue but found nothing.’

  ‘All this Mrs. Bathous could assume at that point was that there’d been some emergency back in London; perhaps Mrs. Gault had some sudden onse
t of illness, or her Chelsea house caught on fire, then apologized for being so melodramatic, but none of that could measure up, for melodrama, to the disappearance of a man’s family. She hadn’t come to thinking in those terms because it was utterly impossible. People don’t disappear like–’

  ‘People disappear all the time,’ said Jury, ‘although not wife, child and dog all at once, I agree. Go on.’

  ‘The agent had been delaying a call to Hugh Gauh, but now she did call, thinking, as I said, there had been an emergency in London.

  When she called him he was dumbfounded. Hugh called Surrey police. Can you imagine telling police your family has disappeared? Just suddenly gone up in smoke? They quite naturally took the position that the missus had done a runner, not that anything had befallen her and her boy.’

  ‘And Mungo.’

  The dog came out from under Jury’s tall bar chair and raised his eyes to look from one to the other.

  Harry smiled. ‘Right. I keep forgetting Mungo.’

  Now the dog turned to Harry Johnson.

  ‘Never mind,’ said Harry, roughing up the top of his head.

  Jury hoped he hadn’t really drunk up this last drink. Well, he forgave himself for this apparent alcoholic thirst; after all he’d just put one hell of a case behind him that had left him really knackered, among other things. He frankly didn’t know if he’d find the energy to get home. Take a cab, he’d have to. ‘Go on,’ he said to Harry.

  ‘The Surrey police came up empty, not surprisingly. But considering there was a nine-year-old child missing, they did make an effort. Their forensics found evidence of tire tracks that matched the brand of tire on Glynnis’s car, but that did no good since the agent knew Glynn had been at the house, the first house, anyway.’